PDA

View Full Version : Repent all you sinners!


zvinki
07-02-2004, 09:09 AM
Read and be saved!

http://www.geocities.com/evilprogressive/index.html

Bob Lentil
07-02-2004, 10:22 AM
"Listeners of progressive rock have often got long and filthy hair, old, colorful and shabby clothes. They smell like marijuana, which is because they smoke it very often! They are usually communists or left-wing liberals, which means they are the enemy of Democracy! They are satanists or new-age -believers. Not many of them are Christians."

I must be an atypical progressive rock listener. I've got short and clean hair (although it used to be really long and clean). My clothes are relatively new and not very colorful, whether they're shabby or not is debatable. I don't smell like marijuana and don't smoke it either. I'm also a right-wing conservative and a Christian.

KeithieW
07-02-2004, 11:27 AM
Man what a JERK!!!!!!!

I guess he dresses in black and Yellow spandex and grooves to Stryper all day long. PRATT!!!!!

progdirjim
07-02-2004, 11:49 AM
No, he's not a jerk. He really believes what he wrote, typos and all. He is SAD. We should PITY him.

Yesspaz
07-02-2004, 12:08 PM
Hey AMers. Yesspaz here. Well, what can I say? By now most of you are aware of the ignorant soul who is the subject of this thread. Now, I won't call him an idiot, I'll just say he's ignorant.

As is fairly well known here, I'm an evangelical Christian. I also host a prog show. So I am the epitome of contradiction to the gentleman in question. So, I wrote him a response on his webpage. I have copied it and posted it here.

I would like to point out that I haven't used AM as an evangelistic platform to try and convert everyone to Christianity. I'm open about my faith, but not pushy. I enjoy the fellowship of other Christians here such as Podakayne, Bob Lentil, and Moses. However, this is a progressive rock site, not a site for the propogation of Christianity. The Bible says in Ecclesiastes 3:1 "There is a time for everything, and a season for every activity under heaven." AM is neither the time nor the place for me to evangelize. Therefore I'd like to put a "disclaimer" on this post. I wrote this quoted post not as a prog fan first, but as a Christian first. After all, it was written from one Christian to another, and is being pasted here for others to "eavesdrop on" because of its subject matter. Therefore, if you read some political statement or otherwise that you disagree with me on, remember that I'm not here to start up a political debate, but to be the voice of reason to this guy. If I offend anyone, I apologize. I don't apologize for what I stand for, but I apologize in general. Anyway, here's what I wrote to the guy:






"I'm a seminary student at Beeson Divinity School in Birmingham, AL. I am also the producer of a progressive rock radio show called BrainRock. I've been an Evangelical Protestant (SBC) Christian since I was 9, and an avid prog fan since I was 13. Your article is so full of fallacies I don't know where to begin.

1. The name Pink Floyd is a reference to two blues musicians, Pink Anderson and Floyd Council. It is not a drug reference, and definitely not "obviously" one.

2. You wrote, "Complex and psychedelic music makes the listener dizzy. A full experience with this music can be only achieved in a drug trip." This is very much your opinion. I love complex and psychedelic music, and it doesn't make me dizzy, nor have I ever used drugs, smoked a cigarette, or even tasted alcohol in my 25 years. This is an ignorant statement.

3. While I agree with you that Amon Dull II's "Pallus Dei" is a disgusting title, this is a rarity amoungst prog. I noticed that the first page description of progressive rock you cut and pasted from www.allmusic.com. In that descprition it states that the lyrics tend to be more literary and based in poetry than the regular rock and roll ideaology of boy-meets-girl, sex, drugs, and rock-n-roll. Trust me, blasphemy like "Phallus Dei" is the exception to the rule (unless the title refers to Jesus' penis - he did have one). Of course, the lyrics of the song would be suspect to inspection. When you mentioned "Hymn 43," "My God," and "Jesus He Knows Me," you picked out exceptions. You didn't mention the thousands that don't fit your criterion. Besides, these non-Christian songs (not UN-Christian) should be looked at as a healthy outside critique of some of the Church's errors. "Jesus He Knows Me" is about the abuses and scandals of TV Evangelists. "My God" states, "He's not the kind you have to wind up on Sunday morn" - which is correct! However, Ian Anderson was stating no one should go to church. He's wrong. But he's right to say that there are a lot of hypocrites who think they can go to church for "fire-insurance" instead of actually living the Christian life.

4. "In the Court of the Crimson King" is about an encounter with Satan, but that doesn't mean it is satanic. The Bible is full of Satanic encounters, but it's not satanic. The lyricist, Pete Sinfeld, may have had a dream in which he encountered Satan and the wrote about it to get it out of his system. Doesn't mean he's a satanist...

5. Nothing wrong with heavy metal, inherently. There are evil heavy metal groups out there, and there are Christian heavy metal groups, such as Guardian, P.O.D., and Stavesacre.

6. You state, "Listeners of progressive rock have often got long and filthy hair, old, colorful and shabby clothes. They smell like marijuana, which is because they smoke it very often!
They are usually communists or left-wing liberals, which means they are the enemy of Democracy!
They are satanists or new-age -believers. Not many of them are Christians. They have no other life than their music." I'm sorry to come off so strong, put this is pure ignorance. Aren't you thinking of the people who follow around The Dead and Phish? I am clean-cut, wear normal clothes, have never even smelled weed, am an extremely right-wing conservative Republican, am not a satanist or new-ager, am a devout Christian, and yes, I do have a life other than music. I'm in school, have a lot of friends in a very active single's ministry at Shades Mountain Baptist Church. In fact, here's link for you to check out: http://www.auralmoon.com/html/modules.php?set_albumName=album10&op=modload&name=gallery&file=index&include=view_album.php It is the Rogues Gallery at Auralmoon.com, a progressive rock radio station ( I'm the guy with the broken foot). While not all of my fellow Auralmoon listeners are Christians, right-wing, or otherwise, you will notice that the vast majority of folks look like "regular folk." And the rest, well, always get to know someone before passing judgement. Some of the best Christians I know would scare little old church ladies just passing them on the sidewalk.

Now, yes, like the woman who had to find a new band every week, prog fans probably buy more music than most people. There are two reasons for this. #1 You don't get to hear it on the radio. #2 By virtue of the seriousness of the style, it tends to attract serious people, who therefore take their music seriously. But this is not to say that we make ourselves broke buying music. This woman who spent 90% of her money on prog had a classic addiction cycle. It just happened to be prog. If she hadn't have been rescued from her addictions by God, it would have become something else. (Basic Psychology 101) If someone is addicted to say, food, and they overeat, they may think that they can cure this addiction. But what happens if they stop eating? Usually, they take up smoking. If someone is a chain-smoker and they stop smoking, maybe they begin to drink more. See, the addiction is not caused by the thing itself, but by the root. People who quit one vice only to pick up another are jumping from one branch to another on the addiction "tree" if you will. The key is to kill the root of the "tree." The root of addiction always has been and always will be "fear of rejection." People feel rejected, they turn to something that makes them feel good; that won't reject them: sex, drugs, alcohol, chocolate, or progressive rock. The problem is that this doesn't reach the cause. Once this woman's sense of rejection was elimated when she accepted Christ's love for her, BOOM, problem solved. Often men addicted to pornography will never tell their wives because of the fear of rejection, but if they ever do, and the wife works through it and forgives him and accepts him, guess what? He doesn't need porn anymore. All that to say, this woman's problem wasn't prog, it was lack of intimacy.

--And finally, my advice to the author of this page, from one evangelical to another:

You are obviously a passionate person for the purity of the gospel and for social awareness, i.e. helping people to stay out of destructive lifestyles. So please consider "looking for bigger fish to fry." There are all kinds of places, much more legitamte, for you to channel this energy. Work on the pro-life cause. Volunteer at Betty Ford clinics. Take some training and learn how to host AA meetings. As the Bible says, "Rescue the perishing; care for the dying." But please, see where the dying are (drugs, alcoholics, people addicted to porn), rather than attacking a generally positive musical form.

God bless, Ben from BrainRock."

podakayne
07-02-2004, 12:43 PM
i could not believe his narrowmindedness...my God i shutter...people such as he scare the Hell out of me...i did respond in his guest book. and i know i don't meet the criteria for "prog folk" acording to him.

and being a former clean-haired, big-afroed hippie i could resent him greatly...but i don't...i pity is tiny little mind.

podakayne
07-02-2004, 12:54 PM
if only the guest page could encompass your well spoken reply. and no appologies needed in my book. i am very proud to be aquainted with you. your rebuttal was very tactful w/attacking, showing restraint for a fellow believer...great work brother...great work.

VAXman
07-02-2004, 01:54 PM
"Man is the religious animal. He is the only religious animal. He is the only animal that has the True Religion –- several of them. He is the only animal that loves his neighbor as himself and cuts his throat, if his theology isn't straight. He has made a graveyard of the globe in trying his honest best to smooth his brother's path to happiness and heaven."

(Mark Twain / 1835 - 1910)



"Listeners of progressive rock have often got long and filthy hair, old, colorful and shabby clothes." Hey, did Jesus listen to prog rock?


"communists or left-wing liberals, which means they are the enemy of Democracy!" ;)

MrMagoo
07-02-2004, 01:58 PM
Literally: "Oh My God"! I'm stunned at such bigotry. Here's my response:

Have you accepted Jesus Christ to your life? : yes, plus Buddha, Buri, Danu, Gaea, and The Great Spirit
Comments : There are so many mis-guided, mis-informed, mis-taken beliefs here I dont know where to start. I feel sorry for your judgemental righteous narrow views. I pray you can expand your mind & soul to love & honor all peoples & ways, not just yours.

And yes, I'm honored to be amongst such reasoned peeplz...

progdirjim
07-02-2004, 03:32 PM
Originally posted by podakayne

and being a former clean-haired, big-afroed hippie

I know this is off topic but I'd LOVE to see a picture of Poda with a big afro...:p

Eating Lemur
07-02-2004, 03:47 PM
I don't know, man...I mean, I did have long hair once, and my clothes are kind of worn. Hell, I'm even a communist and a critic of popular christianity. Does that mean I'm evil? :eek:

progdirjim
07-02-2004, 04:03 PM
Originally posted by Eating Lemur
I don't know, man...I mean, I did have long hair once, and my clothes are kind of worn. Hell, I'm even a communist and a critic of popular christianity. Does that mean I'm evil? :eek:

aren't lemurs endangered? and you're eating them??:D

Wojtek
07-02-2004, 04:05 PM
And because of such guys this faith is 'summed up' by the ironic smile by many people. I
diotic selectiveness, sick intepretations. I think this guy is a fanatic and fanatism doesn't fit to religion the is subsribed to, religion exhorting to love, forgiveness and seeing good in other person. This Christian 'offers' damnation and hate, moreover basing on false and selective arguments.
Big disgust here.

Catholic Woj

Yesspaz
07-02-2004, 04:19 PM
Originally posted by progdirjim
aren't lemurs endangered? and you're eating them??:D Well, what do you expect from a communist spy? ;) :D :eek:

Rick and Roll
07-02-2004, 10:06 PM
so thank you all for giving me the Cliff notes!

And finally a thread by Zvinki that people post to!:eek:

Eating Lemur
07-03-2004, 12:58 AM
Actually, "eating" is an adjective--not a verb.

Anyway, Wojtek's comment about "fanaticism" reminded me of some things I read from Swami Vivekananda, a man whose opinion I respect very much. Courtesy of vivekananda.org, here is what he had to say about fanatacism:

"My experience comes to this, that it is rather wise to avoid all sorts of fanatical reforms. This world is slowly going on; let it go slowly. Why are you in a hurry? Sleep well and keep your nerves in good order; eat right food, and have sympathy with the world. Fanatics only make hatred. Do you mean to say that the temperance fanatic loves these poor people who become drunkards? Fanatics are fanatics simply because they expect to get something for themselves in return. As soon as the battle is over, they go for the spoil. "

I would have just provided a link, but the website is setup so that I couldn't do a direct link to the specific reading, though you are welcome to find it on his site; it is under "readings" (you must click on the flie cabinet thingy) and "notes from classes." I read it again, and that paragraph was one of the most singularly meaningful; the rest is hard to quote because it would sound out of place without the whole article.

Anyway, I just thought I would share some of my evil, so-called "non-christian" views. ;)

zvinki
07-03-2004, 07:20 AM
I would take offence at that if I wasn't so high.

Great replies from everyone especially Spaz who remains an AM paradox. It's interesting that this guy takes a swipe at such a small group as prog-rock lovers instead of larger and more deserving groups like gangsta rap lovers for example. So he's offended the half-dozen of us. Big deal!!! I showed this guyswebsite and rantings to my kids because I have always warned them about the dangers of fanatics hiding in religion and stereotyping. At least it served my purpose well.

kevishev
07-03-2004, 09:01 AM
Originally posted by zvinki

I would take offence at that if I wasn't so high.

Zvinki,

That's the greatest comment I've ever heard.

But anyway, I'm a bit taken aback by the credence being given to this hapless evangelical wannabe by this forum. I'm not surprised that such people exist and purport views and opinions such as those on his website. What surprises me most is that some people here would take the time and effort to be offended by this. Then, to respond to him and defend who they are and the type of music they like to listen to. No offense but, who really gives a shit?

Prog Rock is in no need of defense.

Kev

Let he among you that is without sin, turn down the volume.

Yesspaz
07-03-2004, 12:12 PM
Originally posted by kevishev
Prog Rock is in no need of defense.


Neither is Christianity.


So, why did I take the time to reply?

"Do not answer a fool according to his folly,
or you will be like him yourself.
Answer a fool according to his folly,
or he will be wise in his own eyes."

-Proverbs 26:4-5

Rick and Roll
07-03-2004, 12:25 PM
Originally posted by kevishev
Zvinki,

That's the greatest comment I've ever heard.

But anyway, I'm a bit taken aback by the credence being given to this hapless evangelical wannabe by this forum. I'm not surprised that such people exist and purport views and opinions such as those on his website. What surprises me most is that some people here would take the time and effort to be offended by this. Then, to respond to him and defend who they are and the type of music they like to listen to. No offense but, who really gives a shit?

Prog Rock is in no need of defense.

Kev

Let he among you that is without sin, turn down the volume.

Kev, that's why I didn't read it....................

Zvinki, I was commenting on your two threads that only you and I posted to (the Saga and the FM). Don't you remember? I was making a joke.


Anyway, you're still one behind me on unresponded threads (I had three that were never responded to:(

zvinki
07-03-2004, 08:00 PM
Did you forget Strange Advance?

Of course you were joking! That's why I gave you tongue-in-cheek comment but, alas, not tongue-in-cheek emoticons. :(

Rick and Roll
07-03-2004, 08:27 PM
I realized about three minutes later that I was totally screwed. Just call me Mr. Sensitive and Stupid.

You may be high, but you outsmarted me!

And I did forget Strange Advance. We are tied.

We don't have to go to OT, do we?

"he shoots and scores"!

And may I add you've shown excessive restaint to lay off the Rush thread!

Eating Lemur
07-04-2004, 01:36 AM
Thinking back, it seems to me that some people here were genuinely offended by the site. Just out of curiosity, what has the creator of it done to earn anything more than a good laugh and dismissal?

Looking at it, I can only wonder how serious the real creator could be; there are a few aspects of it that suggest it was created as a joke, such as what appears to be a conscious effort to make the site as cheesy, blatantly stereotypical, and unprofessional as possible. Unfortunately, if it is a spoof, the author is talented enough not to give any explicit tip off (as far as I have read), perhaps with the exception of the cute picture on the main page. ;)

The people who would be interested in the site are primarily those who have mindsets that are already dead set either against the position it states; people who are more ambivalent on the issue are much less likely to care about the site, and that is providing they managed to find it in the first place, since it's not generally accessible on the web but is, rather, distributed almost exclusively between within one of the opposing groups (think about how you discovered the site).

Either way, I say that there is really nothing to fear from old Jerry here, and it's probably not worth getting too hot and bothered about.

Anyway, that's just something I've been thinking about.

roger
07-04-2004, 08:20 AM
sadly, even if that particular site is a spoof, there are certainly people out there that have those thoughts, about prog rock and many other subjects.
we are a curious species, capable of such great ideas and actions(and music!), and also capable of being very narrow-minded and un-willing to think for ourselves.
have a happy 4th, and remember the price of that freedom to think is eternal vigilance. and that's not vigilantes.
:cool:

zvinki
07-04-2004, 09:19 AM
As I stated before, it strikes me as strange and ineffective to target such a small and docile group as ours, therefore, the legitimacy of the site is questioned. But (I know, never start a sentence with "But") I also know that there are a few wackos out there and the internet provides them with a means to contact other similarly minded wackos. The guys claim is a joke, whether intended or not, therefore should not stir any emotion from us except amusement.

To Rick: I have restrained myself from the anti-Rush forum since it seems to me that this guys issue with Rush is personal. Maybe his girlfriend is in love with Geddy Lee, he couldn't learn "The Spirit of Radio" riff, or he's a Naples Florida cop. I'll stay clear of his rants and let him resolve his issues by himself or with some professional help.

mossy
07-04-2004, 10:47 AM
Great thread. Sort of a massive shout box without the refresh.

Skimmed over the diatribe in question. The guestbook was much better.

Rick and Roll
07-04-2004, 12:37 PM
Originally posted by zvinki
Maybe his girlfriend is in love with Geddy Lee



Are you sure?????????:D

Eating Lemur
07-04-2004, 12:39 PM
he couldn't learn "The Spirit of Radio" riff

I'm guilty of that! ;) Interestingly, it's not difficult at all to figure out what's going on (the main part is rather simple and repetative), but the real secret is having the dexterity. I tried it, and my fingers just weren't fast enough. :(

Yesspaz
07-04-2004, 03:44 PM
Originally posted by zvinki
As I stated before, it strikes me as strange and ineffective to target such a small and docile group as ours
Exactly my sentiments, Zvin. That's why I responded to the guy (whom I perceive to be an honest, zealous, and well-meaning, yet misinformend, Christian), encouraging him to channel his energy into the "bigger fish to fry" category. Of course, my convictions on what those fish are may be different than others here, but I think we agree the guy is misguided as comes to prog. Doesn't mean he's an idiot, just ignorant.

kirk
07-04-2004, 04:17 PM
reading that , all i could think of was-

"...and we achieve all this with movement inbetween the sad remark"

Rick and Roll
07-04-2004, 10:32 PM
Originally posted by kirk
reading that , all i could think of was-

"...and we achieve all this with movement inbetween the sad remark"

Please explain, that went over my head....

kirk
07-04-2004, 11:53 PM
sorry rick , i was referring to the person that posted
that ignorant diatribe to his site.

"hippies"(whatever that is) christian
or buddhist, the prog people are simply
some of the most introspective, insightful people
i know.
i'm proud to count myself among them.

p e a c e kirk/zenpool

Rick and Roll
07-05-2004, 12:03 AM
is that a lyric or a famous quote? I just was curious of the origin.

kirk
07-05-2004, 12:56 AM
that's from the end of "close to the edge" bud!:D

Rick and Roll
07-05-2004, 08:32 AM
oh yes..... I think after "how can the wind with its arms all around me" (missing the verb) I have become numb to his lyrics.

:)

kirk
07-05-2004, 11:34 AM
o.k.- we're going to have to take this outside..:D

Rick and Roll
07-05-2004, 11:52 AM
it's a nice day what am I doing inside?

I used to think in "Gates" he said "Kill the laughing children" (I was combining "Kill them" and "should we leave our children". It was my high school buzz acting up again (oops further fodder for our thread starter).

kirk
07-05-2004, 01:06 PM
it's o.k., i'm still waiting on mine to wear off!

the doode's artwork really didn't help:D

i can't think of what grade i was in when i drew
on that level. sometime prior to my "flaming skulls"
period, i think.

k/z

podakayne
07-06-2004, 01:18 PM
rick...i got kirk's Yes quote immediately...as for gates are you did you mean the one below?

as sung by Yes
Kill them...give them as they give us...Slay them...burn their children's laughter...On to Hell

anywho, i like what kirk quoted...makes a perfect ending to me kirk...

an altogether prime reading thread Z!

p.s. rick one day i'll explain the wind with it's arms all around me thingie;)

Rick and Roll
07-06-2004, 01:28 PM
stop eating meat and potatoes and looking at things in black and white and start paying attention to the lyrics! (although the "Soon" section was a special tune in my formative years).

kirk
07-06-2004, 02:02 PM
there's a discussion of this nutcase at yesfans also-
"prog= the devil's music!"

http://www.yesfans.com/forum/showthread.php?t=13742&goto=newpost

the funny thing is- this will probably do more
for prog than against it.
there seems to be an underground sort of
prog swell , discovering and re-discovering.
backlash is a sure sign.

it's been awhile since most of us were part
of an underground, eh?

:cool:

k/z

Rick and Roll
07-06-2004, 02:16 PM
This guy is sincere. His style reminds me of the type of people I cross paths with occasionally. He's harmless....but obnoxious.

I absolutely love the Gentle Giant reference. They're about as satanic as Sponge Bob.

Pretty little site you got there Kirk......

podakayne
07-06-2004, 02:32 PM
of mr. Square pants and the dirty goings on at Bikini bottom, now there's a reference if ever i heard one...Squidworth! and that seemingly idiot starfish...oh the horror of that cartooned den of evil!!!!

kirk
07-06-2004, 03:48 PM
I absolutely love the Gentle Giant reference. They're about as satanic as Sponge Bob.

Pretty little site you got there Kirk...... [/B]

satan works in mysterious ways, eh?:D

'you mean yesfans? it's like a virtual city,
w/ thousands of members.

it's become sort of the "official" fansite w/
a direct link on yesworld.

k/z