The Ladder?

[Lemur]

I haven't heard all of Yes' discography, but I'm a very big Yes fan. The Ladder was a fairly recent release for such an antiquated band, but I borrowed it from my uncle and gave it a shot. At first I wasn't terribly thrilled about it, but over time it really started grow on me and I think it is actually one of their better albums.

What are your guys' opinions on Yes music throughout the ages? They certainly have changed a lot since the beginning.

[yorksrvc]

I LOVE EVERYTHING they've done throughtout. If I have to add an exception, It would be "Tormato". I don't know why, but there's something about that album.......???? I rarely listen to it and when I do try, I never get all the way through it. Believe me, it bothers me.......I keep trying to like it.

[Rick and Roll]

I love Tormato. Played on xmas day a few years back, seemed to fit. If you don't like it that's cool, we'll talk over a beer or eight, neighbor!

It's a bit treble, esp on the first song, that could be a deterrent, York. I had to really do the same with the title track of "Going for the One", that's very high pitched also. Howe's guitar at the end bothers me a bit, but all in all a great song.

I'll only list the Yes I DON'T like. "Open Your Eyes" is an abomination. It sucks, plain and simple.

I've not heard Magnification, but based on recommendations, will get it sometime. "Talk" has a few decent cuts, but I don't see why people love that. Sharc and Spaz are big fans...it sounds great, but "I am Waiting" and "Endless Summer" are overblown, vapid pieces (ok shoot the arrows my way). I've tried to get into it.

90125 and Big Generator came out when I was in college, so I still have a liking to it. but they pissed off old school fans.

[kirk]

Rick: I'll only list the Yes I DON'T like. "Open Your Eyes" is an abomination. It sucks, plain and simple.

Thank you, Rick! "Man in the Moon"- *comic guy voice*-
Worst YES ever!
Rumor has it over at Yesfans than Jon and Chris were attempting
to woo Trevor back, replace Steve.
Damn, w/ politics like that going on, no wonder it sucked.

Rick: I've not heard Magnification, but based on recommendations,
will get it sometime.

Ehh...it's worth picking up. Let's say it- even OK YES is better
than 95% of the stuff out there.

K

[mailotron]

Agree with Open your eyes , very weak material . During the OYE's european tour Yes played the eponym track .
I agree also with Tormato , an LP I listen only from time to time ( it contains however Don't kill the whale and onwards)
On the ladder i like particularily the first and the last track, the pseudo-south american rythmns of some tracks are not of my taste.
My all time fav LP of Yes are in order of preference :
Close to the edge

Tales from Topographic ocean

Relayer

Going for the one

Fragile

The Yes album

Yessongs

Chris Squire and Jon Anderson first solo efforts are also great

[Yesspaz]

The Ladder is a great album. Magnification is a pretty darned good album. I really like Tormato. I think 75% of Tormato is as good as anything they ever did. Only tracks 5 and 6 aren't great.

As for Open Your Eyes, it's a highly flawed album, but it has it's moments. As for that Yesfans rumor about "Jon and Chris were attempting
to woo Trevor back, replace Steve," that's the biggest pile of ever. The truth is in 1996 Yes had finished the Keys to Ascension album and were planning a tour. But they were dragging their feet and the ever-energetic Wakeman was getting frustrated with the waiting around so he left that band - again. Suddenly, with tour dates looming and no way to support a Wakeman album without Wakeman, the band decided to simply take a side-project of Chris' and Billy Sherwood's and Yessify it. It wasn't a group project in the full sense of the word. Squire and Sherwood had demos and Yes simply reworked them really, really fast. So basically, it was a Sherwood solo album that got twisted up.

And for the record, I think that "Man in the Moon" is a great song. The worst Yes song ever is "No Way We Can Lose." Open Your Eyes has some strong stuff, such as "Somehow, Someway" and "Open Your Eyes." But it's got some of the weakest Yes songs with "Fortune Seller" and "The Solution."

Oh yeah, Talk. Talk is a masterwork. In my opinion it's the best Rabin album and one of the top six or seven Yes albums period. "Endless Dream" is the best Yes song after "Awaken." "The Calling" is phenomenal as well.

[Rick and Roll]

Originally Posted by Lemur

What are your guys' opinions on Yes music throughout the ages? They certainly have changed a lot since the beginning.

Lemur, I have a bit of an idea of what you like, but not all, so you'll need to sample "Talk"...at least you have some opinions now (and there are more).

A lot of it has to do with the era you grew up in. You are going back to see what is what, and that is an advantage - I did the same with the 70's bands that I was too young to know, so I heard all the material at once. Then, as the 80's rolled in, I was able to listen to each record as it came out, getting a feel of what was done before (and realizing Queen, Rush, Kansas, Yes were all better in the 70's).

This is why the 50ish crowd looks at late 60's music with such reverence.

Tormato was released when I was in college, and I like it on its on terms. Plus its decidedly Squire, and I like that!

Talk is more of the era Spaz grew up with.

Now that being said, there are exceptions...sharc is a bit older, and loves Talk. But that's my story and I'm sticking to it.

[kirk]

Originally Posted by Rick and Roll

This is why the 50ish crowd looks at late 60's music with such reverence.

I realize I'm not the typical 50-ish listener in any way,
and my opinion is tempered by the fact that I can appreciate
the difficulty of writing these pieces...which some of you should really give
a shot before shredding a tune, but...

I don't see that as the same as a bunch of potbellies at the Rock and Roll
diner listening to Elvis. I won't say "much of", but some of that music
crosses timelines. My Goth daughter's crowd has nothing but respect
for Pink Floyd, the Beatles, and I'm not convinced it was from exposure
as young children.
Spaz is a great example of someone that appreciates music from
before he was born. IMO- He doesn't always understand the context
in which it was created, but I think that's a mindset, rather than an
age thing. There's plenty of young hippies out there...LOL!

Jim's older than spaz, but his mindset is such that he has
a hard time w/ Awaken, Echoes, where my group holds them in high reverence...
as does Spaz. Spaz is younger than my oldest child, so it's hard to see the
age filter in action. We're not used to seeing material hold up this well,
standing the test of time, other than classical, jazz.

What's Miles and Coltrane's shelf life to a jazz fan?
It won't surprise me at all if I have to hide/protect my DSOTM from
being lifted by my grandchildren eventually.

QUOTE=Rick and Roll]
Now that being said, there are exceptions...sharc is a bit older, and loves Talk. B[/quote]

I like Talk! I like Tormato. I haven't played OYE since buying it. P.O'.S., IMO..
even though I saw them twice during that time.

Spaz is welcome to his opinion, although I have a difficult time actually
finding this "record" he speaks of.
Ah, youth...

K

[progdirjim(Admin)]

Originally Posted by kirk

Jim's older than spaz, but his mindset is such that he has
a hard time w/ Awaken, Echoes, where my group holds them in high reverence...

I should clarify that I LIKE Awaken and Echoes, I just get confused when people list them as favorite prog songs ever or favorites from Yes/Floyd. Those songs feel like "obligations" to me. And to emphasize (I think) Kirk's point, even as an old timer (I remember when Relayer and Trilogy and Trick of the Tail were released), I really like a lot of the new music coming out; take a look at the music we're adding to the moon every month - the majority of it is new stuff, released within the last 5 years. The spirit of progressive is NEWNESS, to me...

[kirk]

Originally Posted by progdirjim

The spirit of progressive is NEWNESS, to me...

Exactly! That's the hairsplit, the difference between progressive the act,
or verb, i.e.- Radiohead, and the genre we've come to know as "prog",
which is sometimes anything other than progressive, bands that play
in the style of the 70's, AKA "Neoprog".

I'd have to say I lean toward Progressive bands, or bands that were
progressive in their time. CTTE was progressive in it's day, The
Ladder I'd have to say, isn't. A few nice tunes, but nothing groundbreaking
or advancing the genre.

Yes in some ways, is now forced into a box of having to duplicate their
former sound, not to alienate the following.
I doubt they could get away w/ something as leftfield as Relayer these days.


K

[Yesspaz]

Originally Posted by kirk

I doubt they could get away w/ something as leftfield as Relayer these days.

Whew! I have to disagree. That's EXACTLY what Yes would benefit most from and get away with is something left field. Keys to Ascension was just that. Those sessions were in the style of Yes but sounded like nothing they'd done before. They need some newness too. What's always kept Yes fresh was fresh blood. The Ladder was something great and new because of Igor and Billy - electronics and such (see "Face to Face").

Originally Posted by Jim

...Awaken and Echoes, I just get confused when people list them as favorite prog songs ever or favorites from Yes/Floyd. Those songs feel like "obligations" to me.

While I disagree, I can see what you mean. To me, the "obligatory" Yes song is "Heart of the Sunrise." Everybody seems to think it's sooooooooo great, but it's probably my least favorite 10+ Yes song. I just don't get the popularity of that song. When they play it live people go crazy, and I'm like, "eh, wish they'd played 'Sound Chaser' instead."

Which gives me an idea for a thread: What are the prog rock classics that you just can't see why they are?

[roger]

lemur, it sounds as if you have a rare musical gift. to get to prog along the path that you took, I would guess doesn't happen very often.

but please, people, prove me wrong!


the mind boggles to think what you might do had you grown up with Beethoven and Wagner...

[Lemur]

Haha, surely, you jest! Well, there must be other people in the previous generations that went down the same path that I did, but I'm not sure. For example, I relate very much to my uncle's taste in music, and stuck to a lot of prog throughout the years, although I'm sad to say that he seems to have gone out of the loop once he hit the 80's! I just don't know what happened.

I hope that I have a musical gift (I'm very passionate about music). I'd be lying if I said I didn't think very much about my ideas about music, but if you want to see for yourself you could try listening to some of the musical samples I composed for school; they are on my website whose link is in my signature. I performed them on the keyboard, and to my knowledge they are all original. A lot of my musical ideas never see the light of day, but some day I'll have the income to buy some nice synthesizers and build a workstation for recording and such. ^_^

[Yesspaz]

Fragile to me is not as great as it's reputation. To me it suffers from the solos (why not create full group pieces in your Yes Album-Going heyday?), the overrated Heart of the Sunrise, and the overplayed Roundabout. It's not even in my top ten Yes albums.

Oh, and I don't know about OYE having a Jon solo song on it, but I know that Man in the Moon was a Chris Squire solo song that they took while in panic mode.

[Rick and Roll]

Originally Posted by Yesspaz

Fragile to me is not as great as it's reputation. To me it suffers from the solos (why not create full group pieces in your Yes Album-Going heyday?), the overrated Heart of the Sunrise

Because they wanted to introduce each member of the band. Close to the Edge is same lineup, full pieces. The solos are short anyway.

Overrated, no. rated just fine.

PFD, agreed about the KTA studios. I love Footprints!

[Thor]

For Yes they hit creative peaks throughout their career yet only a few albums
actually rise to the top here is a discography dot biorhythm with release dates:


• 1969 July 25 YES
•• 1970 July TIME AND A WORD
•• 1971 March 19 THE YES ALBUM
••• 1971 November 1 FRAGILE
••••• 1972 September 13 CLOSE TO THE EDGE
••• 1973 May 4 YESSONGS
••••• 1974 January 9 TALES FROM TOPOGRAPHIC OCEANS
•••• 1974 December 5 RELAYER
•• 1975 February 27 YESTERDAYS
••••• 1977 July 7 GOING FOR THE ONE
•••• 1978 September 20 TORMATO
•• 1980 August 18 DRAMA
•• 1980 November 24 YESSHOWS
• 1981 November 30 CLASSIC YES
•• 1983 November 7 90125
• 1985 November 9012LIVE
• 1987 September 17 BIG GENERATOR
•••• 1989 June 20 ANDERSON, BRUFORD, WAKEMAN, HOWE
••• 1991 April 30 UNION
••• 1991 August 6 YESYEARS
•• 1991 October 13 YESSTORY
• 1993 September 21 HIGHLIGHTS - THE VERY BEST OF YES
•• 1993 October 26 SYMPHONIC MUSIC OF YES
•••• 1994 March 4 AN EVENING OF YES MUSIC...PLUS
••• 1994 March 21 TALK
• 1996 October 29 KEYS TO ASCENSION (live disc)
••• 1996 October 29 KEYS TO ASCENSION (studio disc)
• 1997 November 4 KEYS TO ASCENSION 2 (live disc)
•• 1997 November 4 KEYS TO ASCENSION 2 (studio disc)
•• 1997 November 25 OPEN YOUR EYES
•••• 1998 April 28 BEYOND AND BEFORE (BBC tapes)
• 1999 September 28 THE LADDER
• 2000 February 22 THE BEST OF YES
•••• 2000 September 12 HOUSE OF YES LIVE FROM HOUSE OF BLUES
••••• 2001 December 4 MAGNIFICATION
••• 2002 July 9 KEYSTUDIO
••• 2002 July 30 IN A WORD: YES 1969-
•• 2003 July 28 ULTIMATE YES: 35TH ANNIVERSARY COLLECTION
•• 2003 August 25 THE YES STORY GOLD

[PFD]

What do those dots mean?

[kirk]

Thor- 5 dots to Magnification, 1 to Big Generator? I don't think so.

To anyone that doesn't understand the appeal of Heart of the Sunrise-
Buy a guitar.(or drum, or bass), come back and post when you've managed to
play it through....just once. see you next incarnation.

Rick- Fragile's a masterpiece.

RE: Man in the Moon- I don't care who wrote it. It sucketh verily.
I could assemble a band from this site that could write a better tune.

K

[Lemur]

Originally Posted by kirk

To anyone that doesn't understand the appeal of Heart of the Sunrise-Buy a guitar.(or drum, or bass), come back and post when you've managed to play it through....just once. see you next incarnation.

I like the song for its emotional content.. as far as raw complexity goes, I'm pretty sure that Yes has some trickier pieces. I say this as a guitarist myself, though not nearly so talented! It's just that my ears tell me that Heart of the Sunrise, while stirring and at times fast paced example of Yes music, is not the creme de la creme of Yes creme.

[Yesspaz]

Originally Posted by Lemur

It's just that my ears tell me that Heart of the Sunrise, while stirring and at times fast paced example of Yes music, is not the creme de la creme of Yes creme.

I so totally agree.