Big Generator

[Roger -Dot- Lee(Admin)]

Originally posted by MrMagoo
That's not a rant, that's a munchies flashback...

Note to self: Don't rant when hungry.

Originally posted by Roger Lee
Note to self: Don't rant when hungry.

Dr Dot...........may I suggest you go to your Gallery pick, reach out and grab the floating DNA and reimplant it. It may help you get over this Yes catalogue madness.

[RogorMortis]

If the unthinkable happened that Yes would be removed then Dot would have the biggest revolt in history that would be measured on the Richter scale.

It would also include the utter demand that ALL Godspeed and Tarantel be removed immeadiately.

So lets's just keep it as it is. Thank you.

[Roger -Dot- Lee(Admin)]

Originally posted by RogorMortis
If the unthinkable happened that Yes would be removed then Dot would have the biggest revolt in history that would be measured on the Richter scale.

I would have no such thing -- since I'd be joining in.

It would also include the utter demand that ALL Godspeed and Tarantel be removed immeadiately.

demands that would be met with all the attention they so richly deserve.

So lets's just keep it as it is. Thank you.

So tell me, RM, are you the ONLY one that read my post that didn't catch on to the fact that I may well have been JOKING about the entire affair? Do you HONESTLY think that, after signing that I'd seen the band FIVE times, that I'd be lobbying for their removal? Perhaps after I'd seen a band ONCE and realized that it was a crock, I might. But five times tends to mean that I LIKE the band (we don't have mandatory concert attendance here in the states -- we can go see whatever we like). And Jim's post was in regards to posting the comment to generate a response, not as a warning of things to come.

Did you even READ what was said? Or did your knee-jerk reaction unplug your monitor or something?

Just curious, mind.

Roger -Dot- Lee, shouldn't have to explain this stuff

[Rick and Roll]

there was some interesting discussion on this topic. Please refer to the older posts.

[Yesspaz]

Tarentel cannot be removed. See, I hacked in and did some secret thing that only I know in which those tracks became integrated into the hard-wiring. See, it's futile.

Also, I'd add all the Yes that's not here, but that's just me.

Oh, and Calling All Stations ain't so bad, Rick...

[progdirjim(Admin)]

Originally posted by Yesspaz
Tarentel cannot be removed. See, I hacked in and did some secret thing that only I know in which those tracks became integrated into the hard-wiring. See, it's futile.

Also, I'd add all the Yes that's not here, but that's just me.

Oh, and Calling All Stations ain't so bad, Rick...

for the record, on this one issue, Spaz is wrong, wrong and wrong. But I have no desire to remove Tarentel, I'm not likely to add any Yes that isn't already here (barring a new good album), and Calling All Stations sucks.

sorry bud...

and people (I'm not referring to Spaz, Dot, Rick, Goo or Keithie), please read the entire thread before offering ADVICE. The thread is 2 years old, and began with the question of should I remove part of Big Generator. And, I already responded that I wasn't going to. All other topics are rhetorical.

[Rick and Roll]

Originally posted by progdirjim
I'm not likely to add any Yes that isn't already here (barring a new good album

and people (I'm not referring to Spaz, Dot, Rick, Goo or Keithie), please read the entire thread before offering ADVICE.

I kind of said that but didn't come right out and say it dirctly (about advice), well said.

I think there's too many live Yes and Crimsons on here anyway.

[Yesspaz]

Originally posted by progdirjim
I'm not likely to add any Yes that isn't already here

What about the previously unreleased bonuses from the Drama remaster? and the song "Show Me" which is the only new song recorded since Wakeman came back?

[Roger -Dot- Lee(Admin)]

Originally posted by progdirjim
and Calling All Stations sucks.

I'm afraid I'm going to have to offer a mild disagreement on this statement. Calling All Stations doesn't just suck, it tends to suck so bad that it does things that are illegal in 27 states and the District of Columbia.
[/quote][/b]

The thread is 2 years old,[/b][/quote]

I read this section and thought "nah, can't be THAT old."

Then I did a little math.

GEH. I'm getting OLD!

Roger -Dot- Lee, Time's sure fun when you're flying...or something...

[Rick and Roll]

Originally posted by Roger Lee


I'm afraid I'm going to have to offer a mild disagreement on this statement. Calling All Stations doesn't just suck, it tends to suck so bad that it does things that are illegal in 27 states and the District of Columbia.

[/b]

The thread is 2 years old,[/b][/quote]

I read this section and thought "nah, can't be THAT old."

Then I did a little math.

GEH. I'm getting OLD!

Roger -Dot- Lee, Time's sure fun when you're flying...or something... [/b][/quote]

My beef with that record is that it's not Ray Wilson's fault. It's Banks and Rutherford with lame-ass songwriting.